Your batteries are only as good as your weakest one. If you are adding a new battery you want to make sure your old one is in good shape or replace both. Put your old battery in the wife's van or something like that; treat your fishing buddy to two new ones.
When servicing batteries always remove the negative cable first. With parallel batteries you have to remove
both negatives or the potential for grounding a positive still exists.
Sorry if this is stating the obvious but I have been surprised by some people who should know better and always start with the positive.