Walleye wrote:
Hi all.
Don. I agree with your post for the most part. I think that fizzing the fish is an attempt to revive the fish where as poking the bladder with a knife and popping the bladder is the surest way to kill a fish. I put a post on about a year ago on fizzing and how to do it. The ethics of doing so are up to each of us. My opinion is that any attempt to revive a fish is better than no attempt and in the case of properly fizzing a fish, I am told by fishery biologists is effective. My experience has also shown that it works at least in the short term.
There are other ways that can be effective as well. Clipping weights to the fish's pectoral fins allow the fish to sit in the live well in the upright position allowing it to adjust the bladder.
The only tournements I have fished are live release Walleye tournements where the fish are usually inspected by a biologist at the weigh in. The judge determines if the fish is alive, dead or stressed. Live fish get weighed in, dead fish do not and you lose one fish for each dead one and stressed fish recieve a penalty. I have seen anglers posed with a conundrum in that they have the allowed number of fish in the live well. One of those fish is bellied but still gilling. Will the fish die if nothing is done? Do I fizz the fish knowing that I can be sure the fish will pass as live at the weigh in? Do I attempt the weight method and take a chance that once the weights are removed it will bellie again? Do I throw the fish overboard and watch the gulls do what they do best? Do I poke the bladder with a knife and sink the fish so that there is no evidence of my treachery?
These questions arise whether I am in a tournement or fishing with my kids and I have seen that fizzing if done properly seems to give the stressed fish it's best chance.
I think that every time I release a fish I have done my best to ensure it survives, but I will never know for sure.
I am coming to Quinte and will try my hand at the tournement on th 13th if I can find a partner. Hopefully I will catch something this year as last year I had to enjoy watching other people get the net out.
Cheers Clark
Which fish biologists stated that fizzing was effective? A 2001 MNR publication entitled "A review of Fizzing - a Technique for Swim Bladder Deflation" states unequivocally in the executive summary "... the widespread use of fizzing should be discouraged in Ontario". Additionally, besides Ontario, Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Yukon, Quebec and New Brunswick don't advocate fizzing.
So whats a sportfisherman to do?
Fish shallower!! According to the same report, " to maximize post-release survival, walleye should not be taken at depths exceeding 7.5 meters".